Christian Mingle app 2022 reviews: Is it worth it?

We get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Here's more on how we make money.

Unless you meet someone directly through church, it can be hard as a Christian to find a partner who shares your religious beliefs (let alone with whom you connect in other areas).

Luckily, if you're a single Christian looking for love, there are numerous dating apps, like Christian Mingle, that put faith at the forefront of the online dating experience. I recently took a closer look at Christian Mingle to see if it's worth using for single Christian daters.

Is Christian Mingle worth it?

Like all dating sites, whether or not Christian Mingle is worth it will depend on where you live, your own profile, preferences, the time and energy you put into it — and of course, luck.

If you consider yourself a Christian, you’re probably wondering:

a) Do people still use Christian Mingle? 

b) Is it possible to find love on Christian Mingle?

Christian Mingle does devote itself to Christian singles, though what that means to each member may be different (there are currently more than 15 million users). However, if Christianity is important to you, this site is worth a look.

Our No. 1 dating app recommendation for Christians is actually not branded as a Christian at all. eharmony is the leading dating site for those seeking long-term partnership, with an emphasis on religious affiliation.

We like eharmony for Christian dating because:

  • A- Better Business Bureau rating
  • Scientifically proven to assist with more marriages and very low divorce – rates when compared with other dating sites, quantified in a study – published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
  • Matches based on a deep personality questionnaire that emphasizes spirituality and religion
  • eharmony's founder Neil Clark Warren is a Christian theologian and seminary professor who developed the app based on his belief in the value of partnership and marriage.

Learn more about eharmony in our review, or try eharmony for free now, or get 25% off a membership with code WSM25 >>

Or, learn more about Christian Mingle and whether or not it’s worth checking out:

What is Christian Mingle?

Christian Mingle is a faith-based dating site that caters to people who practice any denomination of Christianity. Launched in 2001, today it’s still filled with over 16 million active members looking to meet someone who shares similar beliefs.

Is Christian Mingle still active?

Christian Mingle is still very much active and one of the most popular Christian dating apps and sites on the market.

Christian Mingle reviews

Christian Mingle is not accredited by the Better Business Bureau, but its parent company Sparks Network (owner of other dating services like Zoosk and JDate) is accredited with an A+ rating. While there’s one customer review about Christian Mingle (regarding canceling a subscription), Sparks Network does a great job with customer service, responding to every query.

Christian Mingle app reviews on Trustpilot

On Trustpilot, it receives 1.8 out of five stars. Reviewers call it “a scam” and that it’s “not a true Christian dating site.” Lots of reviewers write about being scammed by fake users on the site and how the cost of the premium membership isn’t worth the experience.

Christian Mingle app reviews on Reddit

On Reddit, users are frustrated with meeting people on the dating site. “I feel that there are more people with free memberships than those who pay, further restricting your chance of making a connection,” writes one user.

Other users find that meeting people on Christian Mingle is hard when you’re above the age of 30. “My greatest downfall is that I do not want to go out with someone who already has kids, but going from 31 years single to instead doesn't seem prudent to me, and this makes me some kind of monster apparently,” writes another user.

Lastly, multiple reviewers on Reddit and Trustpilot complain that there aren’t that many devoted Christians on Christian Mingle — the definition of which is up for debate, of course.

How does Christian Mingle work?

1. Creating a profile on Christian Mingle is quick and easy:

2. Go to ChristianMingle.com or download the app. Sign up using your Facebook or Apple ID credentials, sign up using your email. 

3. Upload at least one photo of yourself.

4. Answer basic questions, such as your religion, marital status, whether or not you want kids, and how often you go to church. Christian Mingle only gives you the option to be divorced, never-married or widowed — no swingers or cheaters welcome here!

Sign up process for Christian mingle dating site.

Sign up process for Christian mingle dating app.
Sign up process for Christian mingle dating app.

5. Fill out your “about me” section! Christian Mingle suggests writing a dating bio that’s honest about what you’re looking for as well as your relationship to God (This is a Christian dating site, after all!). Pro tip: Christian Mingle really pays attention to how detailed you get with your profile. You cannot interact with other members until you fill this out.

6. Select different your favorite activities and interests to show your matches what you like to do. 

7. Share what you’re looking for. Are you seeking a man or a woman? Are you looking for a friend/activity partner or something more serious? You can also filter matches based on church attendance, drinking habits, and other preferences.

8. Once your dating profile is set up, you’re asked to upgrade your plan for a premium subscription (more on that later). You can skip this step and go straight using the site. You can filter matches based on who’s online, distance, and match percentage (Christian Mingle’s way of showing you how compatible you are with other users.). There’s also a Lookbook feature that allows you to anonymously browse one profile at a time. It works very similar to dating apps, where you can tap a “heart” button to like a profile or tap “x” to reject it.

As a free user, you can like other profiles and send smiles, but messaging is a paid feature, making Christian Mingle tricky to use without a subscription.

How much does it cost to join Christian Mingle?

Signing up for Christian Mingle is free, but to get the most out of this dating website, you need to pay. Below we’ll compare both plans to show you why it might be worth getting a premium membership.

The premium plan costs:

  • $49.99/month
  • $34.99/month with a 3-mo. contract
  • $24.99/month with a 6-mo. contract

What you get with using Christian Mingle’s free version:

  • Upload up to six photos on your profile.
  • Search for profiles.
  • Receive emails when you get matches.
  • Option to purchase the Spotlight feature that makes your profile stand out on top of the page.

What you get with using Christian Mingle’s premium membership

  • Access to photos.
  • Send and reply to messages.
  • Read receipts.
  • Advanced privacy controls that allow you to hide your profile from matches and browse anonymously.

Is Christian Mingle a good dating site? Pros and cons

Pros of the Christian Mingle app:

It's easy to find common ground with other people.

If you’re using a Christian Mingle, chances are you really value your faith. Having that commonality can make it easy to break the ice with other members.

Christian Mingle really wants you to meet people.

Christian Mingle encourages users to take dating seriously. For one, you can’t interact with other members until you fill out your bio. They also offer match percentages. These numbers are like compatibility scores to help you see how your preferences and interests compare to other profiles. And lastly, Christian Mingle also offers daily match suggestions based on your preferences to keep you engaged and dating, even when you get discouraged.

It's great if you’re looking for a serious long-term relationship.

People on Christian Mingle are either looking to make friendships or looking for something serious — there is no in-between.

Cons of the Christian Mingle app:

It’s expensive to use.

As mentioned, you cannot do much on the dating site unless you pay for a premium membership. This can be a big dealbreaker for the budget-minded singles. (In that case, you might want to try a site like OkCupid or Plenty of Fish, which offers a lot of free features for users.

It's hard to interact with other members.

Because you need a premium membership to send, read, and reply to messages, it can be a challenge to connect with users, let alone get asked out on a date. In fact, plenty of reviews on Trustpilot and Reddit echo this sentiment. 

There aren’t any background checks. Read: How to run a background check

Tons of reviews on Trustpilot say that Christian Mingle is full of fake profiles and spam, suggesting that dating sites might be doing their best at verifying users — especially as to whether or not they’re actually Christian. This might be an issue for singles who take their faith seriously and are looking for other people who match up to their beliefs, and are not cheats or other red flags.

Does Christian Mingle actually work?

Despite the negative complaints, there have been some success stories on Christian Mingle. One user met his wife on the dating site. “I weeded through a lot of people that matched with me but weren't necessarily of the same denomination,” writes one Reddit user. “Pretty soon I was matched with a pretty girl and it turned out we had mutual friends. Been married 4 years and have a great life.”

“It may not be for everyone, but it worked for me,” writes another user who met her husband on Christian Mingle. “There are all different types of Christians on Christian Mingle, so you’ll still have to be selective if you’re looking for a specific set of beliefs.” 

What is the success rate of Christian Mingle?

Ultimately, it may take some time and an open mind, but it is possible to find love on Christian Mingle. In fact, they have a page dedicated to their success stories of Christians who found love and marriage on the app.

Is eharmony or Christian Mingle better?

eharmony is a popular dating site for those seeking long-term relationships. The website prides itself on its compatibility testing to help singles find love. It’s a dating website that many people consider. Here’s how it stacks up against Christian Mingle.

Cost:

eharmony’s premium membership costs more than Christian Mingle. A six-month membership in eharmony is $49.43 per month for six months, versus $24.99 per month for six months on Christian Mingle. But people say the cost of eharmony is worth it. There are more than 10 million active users on eharmony (750,000 paid memberships) and the dating app is known for creating happy relationships and marriages with a very low divorce rate, which is quantified in a study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Features:

eharmony’s sign-up is long, thanks to its lengthy questionnaire. But it’s for a good reason: this questionnaire helps eharmony pair you with matches that meet your hopes, dreams, and criteria — including your religious and spiritual preferences. In fact, eharmony's founder Neil Clark Warren is a psychologist, Christian theologian and seminary professor who developed the app based on his belief in the value of partnership and marriage.

That questionnaire results in very descriptive profiles, making it easier for people to connect and chat. While Christian Mingle encourages users to be descriptive with their profiles, it’s up to them to decide how much or how little information to add.

eharmony also has a state-of-the-art ID verification. Christian Mingle? Not so much. 

Reviews:

eharmony is one of the very few dating websites that is accredited with an A- rating with the Better Business Bureau (as mentioned, Christian Mingle is not, though its parent company, Spark Networks, has an A+ rating). However, eharmony has a much lower Trustpilot rating with a 1.4 out of five stars. While most reviews are from angry users calling it a scam, they’ve recently have had some positive reviews saying it’s been a good experience.

In terms of which dating app is better, eharmony might be worth the price, especially if you’re serious about a long-term relationship. It not only puts compatibility first, but it’s also a great option if you’re willing to meet people outside your religion.

eharmonyChristian Mingle
Free versionSo-soRead full profiles (though no photo access), reply to messages
Price $49.43 per month for six months$24.99 per month for six months
Discount?Get 25% off eharmony with code WSM25 >>N/A
BBB ratingA-N/R
Number of paid users750,000 unknown
Profile validationYes, excellentNo

Bottom line: Is the Christian Mingle app worth it?

The only way to figure out whether or not Christian Mingle is worth it is to try it yourself. Dating apps and sites vary based on location, age, and what you’re specifically looking for. If you’re of the Christian faith and are looking for a long-term relationship, it might be worth giving it shot. 

If partnership is a priority in your dating, and you hope to meet a Christian, check out eharmony now and get a 25% discount with code WSM >>

Interested in checking out other dating sites and apps? Here are some dating app reviews:

13 international
dating apps
ZooskPlenty of Fish
Elite Singles SingleParentMeetMatch.com
BumbleOKCupidCatholic dating sites
Coffee Meets BagelTinder

Is Christian Mingle worth it?

Like all dating sites, whether or not Christian Mingle is worth it will depend on where you live, your own profile, preferences, the time and energy you put into it.

What is Christian Mingle?

Christian Mingle is a faith-based dating site that caters to people who practice any denomination of Christianity. Launched in 2001, today it’s still filled with over 16 million active members looking to meet someone who shares similar beliefs.

Is Christian Mingle still active?

Christian Mingle is still very much active and one of the most popular Christian dating apps and sites on the market.

How much does it cost to join Christian Mingle?

Signing up for Christian Mingle is free, but to get the most out of this dating website, you need to pay. Below we’ll compare both plans to show you why it might be worth getting a premium membership.

Does Christian Mingle actually work?

Despite the negative complaints, there have been some success stories on Christian Mingle. One user met his wife on the dating site.

Christian Mingle

5

Rating

5.0/10

Pros

  • Easy to find common ground with others
  • Encourages users to take dating seriously
  • Great if you’re looking for a serious long-term relationship

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Hard to interact with others
  • No background checks

Bianca Mendez is a writer and editor living in New York City. Her work has appeared in Woman’s Health, Bustle, Latina, Refinery29, and many other publications. She also served as a sex and dating editor at Elite Daily and a freelance lifestyle editor for Bauer Publishing’s Teen Department, where she helped the team launch three new magazines.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.