scroll top

How to sell Cartier jewelry for the most money

We get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Here's more on how we make money.

Do you have a Cartier diamond ring, earrings, LOVE bracelet, or Cartier Tank watch that you no longer love or wear? There are safe, secure ways to sell Cartier jewelry quickly, for the highest price in cash since Cartier does not buy back their jewelry.

If you have Cartier jewelry that no longer fits your taste—perhaps an inheritance, a gift from an ex, or something that you used to love but no longer do—you might be wondering how and where you can sell your jewelry.  

If your old jewelry is worth more than $1,000, our recommendation is Worthy.com, an online jewelry marketplace that will auction your item to hundreds of jewelry buyers. Worthy is a good choice because:

  • Great reputation:. In addition to its Better Business Bureau A+ review rating, and hundreds of customer testimonials, Worthy has been featured in reputable publications including the New York Times (twice), Crain’s New York Business, Washington Post, Entrepreneur, Reader’s Digest, Woman’s Day, and others.  
  • Free GIA lab report with every sale
  • Free FedEx shipping
  • Free Lloyds of London insurance up to $100,000
  • Auction platform helps drive prices to market highs

Read our Worthy.com review to learn more about our No. 1 recommendation for places to sell large jewelry and watches, or get a free Worthy estimate now >>

Worthy only accepts items that will sell for at least $1,000. If you have smaller jewelry, or gold, silver, gemstone jewelry, coins or flatware, we recommend DiamondsUSA. Read our review.

Keep reading for more details about where and how to sell Cartier:

Where to sell a Cartier watch or jewelry

Thankfully, there are reputable places where you can be assured you will get a great price selling your Cartier jewelry or watch with a company with a good reputation. Options to sell Cartier include:

  • Auction houses
  • Jewelry stores
  • Pawn shops
  • Online marketplaces

Sell Cartier at a pawn shop

If you decide to sell Cartier jewelry to a pawnshop, the deal will be fast but the payoff will be dismal. On average, a pawn shop pays only about 13% of an item’s original purchase price.

Jewelry store near you

If you know and trust a jeweler, it won’t hurt to ask. If you sell Cartier jewelry to a local store, you won’t get top dollar, though, because the store has to make money on the deal. 

A professional jeweler can give you a ballpark figure for the replacement value of that LOVE bracelet, Tank watch or other Cartier jewelry. Some will appraise for free; others will charge $50 to $150 per hour. 

Cartier does not offer jewelry appraisals.

Sell at a jewelry auction

Sotheby’s, Christie’s and other big auction houses also help sell Cartier and other fine jewelry through a consignment process. The problem is that you have to be close to one in a large city like New York, London or Hong Kong to meet with Sotheby’s in person. Other online jewelry auctions are often interested in brands like Cartier, but can take a long time to sell, take a large commission, require lab certification or other barriers.

Sell Cartier online to a reputable jewelry buyer

Don’t live in a major city where you could auction your Cartier? There are several quality places to sell your jewelry online.

How to sell Cartier to a professional buyer online

You will likely fetch more for your Cartier jewelry if you sell to a professional buyer who understands the value of what you have. Professional buyers include auction houses, some online consigners, and online jewelers. 

To find a reputable professional buyer, research client reviews and third-party reviews like the Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot. Worthy has an A+ rating (accredited) from the BBB and 4.7/5 stars from Trustpilot.

How to sell a Cartier watch or jewelry online for the most money with Worthy.com

Tens of thousands of people have successfully sold their designer jewelry to Worthy.com, which earns the company shout-outs in publications like The New York Times, Reuters, Harper’s Bazaar, and Town and Country. Worthy is a member of the American Gem Society. The business is highly rated, secure and offers a fair price, customers say. Better Business Bureau gives Worthy an A+ More:

Worthy bases its offer on a certified lab report from GIA that it pays for, and you receive for free. A lab report generally costs from $100 to $200. However, Worthy.com commissions a lab report for each piece it accepts – and it gives you a free copy of your lab report, even if you decide not to sell your jewelry after all.

Grading takes place at laboratories, such as the International Gemological Institute (IGI) or the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), and includes details about the gemstones, metals and an estimated resale price based on the thousands of pieces of jewelry the laboratories see each year.

Worthy also has an A+ Better Business Bureau, and a 4.8-star rating on Trustpilot, based on more than 1,750 reviews. All jewelry is tracked and insured for up to $100,000 from the moment you send it off until you get paid (or request the item be returned to you, which Worthy will do free of charge).

The selling process is pretty simple.

  1. Fill out the evaluation tool online.
  2. The company will use that info to determine its potential value.
  3. Worthy will send you a FedEx label, which you print, and package to ship via FedEx. You can track your package every step of the way.
  4. Once your jewelry arrives at Worthy’s New York City headquarters, it is tracked by video through the entire process. 
  5. Your item is given a lab report from GIA or another professional laboratory, and then you can set terms of an auction. 

Once your Cartier jewelry is sold, payment is sent within 24 hours by Paypal or check — your choice.

Sell your Cartier jewelry or watch now with Worthy >>

What you should know about Cartier

Since its beginnings in 1847 Paris, Cartier has created jewelry that’s tasteful, refined and sophisticated. King Edward VII called Cartier “the jeweler of kings and the king of jewelers.”

Why is Cartier so expensive?

Popular luxury jewelry brands are more expensive than generic fine jewelry thanks to both their perceived and actual values — but Cartier jewelry holds its value more than many other luxury jewelry and watch brands, according to data from resale site RealReal, which found that ​​the Cartier “Love” collection sells for 78% of its original retail price on average, and competing site Fashionphile’s data reveals that value for the white gold Cartier LOVE bracelet rose 21% in 2021, and the yellow gold version rose in value by 13%.

Cartier watches are particularly good at holding their value. In fact, Watches Guild reports that not only do many Cartier watches hold their resale value, but their resale value can be more than their original value. This is often because they are in high demand.

Is the Cartier resale value high?

According to online consignment site The RealReal, and reported by National Jeweler magazine, Cartier holds the highest resale value of all high-end jewelry brands. Tieing with Van Cleef & Arpels, Cartier jewelry sells for an average of 74% of the original price.

Since Cartier is a world-famous brand, the resale market is strong. Your jewelry’s rarity, current condition and the popularity of the style will determine its potential value. 

If there is a special story about your piece’s provenance, documentation about its history and past ownership, the value can go up exponentially — especially if the piece was once owned by someone famous or noteworthy. 

Similarly, if your Cartier jewelry is in its original box, with any sales receipts, lab reports or other documentation, this adds interest and raises the potential buyer’s confidence that your piece is legitimate. 

Check out this video from Antiques Roadshow of a woman selling a Cartier watch:

To get an accurate jewelry appraisal for your Cartier’s resale value, though, you need a grading (also known as a lab report). You can’t get this at the neighborhood jeweler near you. Cartier also does not offer jewelry appraisals.

How much are Cartier watches and jewelry worth?

The resale value of a Cartier watch, LOVE bracelet, or other item can largely depend on the condition of the pre-owned item. Read below to see what individual Cartier pieces are worth based on recent sales on Worthy.com.

How much can I sell my Cartier watch for?

A few recent Cartier sales from Worthy.com include $2,396 for a Santos, $2,553 for a Tank model and $5,197 for a Dumont. A specialty Cartier watch design called La Doña (inspired by the glamorous Mexican actress Maria Felix) recently sold for $11,070.

How much can I sell my Cartier LOVE bracelet for?

According to Rebag, Cartier LOVE bracelets hold 102% of their original value on the resale market, so you may be able to get a good return if you sell your bracelet.

Diamond LOVE bracelets tend to sell for more, but recently Worthy.com sold an 18k white gold design for nearly $3,000, and an 18k gold LOVE bracelet bangle with diamonds sold for $6,294.

Cartier Love Diamond Bracelet in 18k gold with 10 round, natural diamonds weighing 0.90 – 1.01 carats, sold via Worthy:

Example bracelet if you want to sell Cartier jewelry.

As mentioned, Cartier LOVE bracelets and other Cartier bracelets are very popular and increasing in value. Search recent sales at Worthy.com to understand what your Cartier bracelet may be worth and consider using Worthy to sell your item.

How much can I sell my Cartier diamond for?

Recent Worthy sales of Cartier diamond rings:

$13,226: 1.53 ct. Round Cut Solitaire Cartier Ring, E, VS1

$5,200: 0.85 ct. Round Cut Solitaire Cartier Ring, D-E, VVS2-VS1

$1,770: 0.61 ct. Round Cut Solitaire Cartier Ring, G, VVS2

Learn more about how to sell diamonds

How much can I sell my Cartier ring for?

Cartier rings have been around since the company began. Depending on its age, condition and singularity, your Cartier ring could bring a very decent sum. Recently a round-cut gold ring with numerous small diamonds (about 3.47 carats total) was auctioned for $8,694 at Worthy.com.   

The sum that you can sell Cartier panther ring, Cartier LOVE ring or another style for depends on the going resale value. Some recent resale prices are in the range of $1,200 to $13,000.

Example diamond ring if you want to sell Cartier jewelry.

How much can I sell my Cartier necklace for?

Here are some recent sales of Cartier necklaces on Worthy.com:

18K Yellow Gold Cartier Love necklace, 3 brilliant-cut diamonds for $1,027.

White Gold Pendant Necklace with 0.36 TCW Diamonds on Chain recently sold to Worthy for $1,754:

Example necklace if you want to sell Cartier jewelry.

To understand the value of your Cartier necklace, check recent sales at online jewelry buyer Worthy.com. You can sell your Cartier necklace on Worthy, which is our preferred place to sell Cartier jewelry.

Should you sell your Cartier jewelry?

Maybe your grandparents gave you a Cartier necklace on your 16th birthday, or you inherited your grandmother’s 1940s-era Cartier earrings. Perhaps your first serious boyfriend surprised you with a LOVE bracelet one Christmas. Could be that your now ex-husband splurged on a Cartier engagement ring (and then kept telling everyone how much it cost). Now you’re divorced.

However, if you no longer wear or enjoy your Cartier jewelry, it is best to cleanse your jewelry box, let go of those negative or complicated emotions, take the money and invest it in something positive and joyful — a house downpayment, a well-deserved vacation, going back to school, paying pay off debt, or buying yourself a new piece of jewelry that you will love and wear. It might be time to finally sell your Cartier jewelry.

Why you should sell your used Cartier jewelry (including your Cartier LOVE Bracelet)

Sure, a lot of women would kill for a LOVE bracelet or a Tank watch, or even a simple Cartier necklace or earrings. Fine for them. But if the jewelry is no longer meaningful to you, there’s no reason to keep it. 

And since really there’s no such thing as a “simple” piece of Cartier jewelry, you stand to gain big-time by selling the unwanted jewelry.

In addition, there are a few other reasons to consider selling:

  • It’s practical. Why hang on to jewelry (or anything, really) that isn’t making you happy? You can sell these pieces and use that money for an investment, vacation, pay off debt, go back to school, start a business, or help your kids go to college.
  • It’s no longer your style.Maybe the Cartier jewelry simply isn’t your style these days (especially if it’s that engagement ring that your now-ex just couldn’t shut up about). Maybe you’ve decided to pare down your possessions and declutter your life.
  • The resale value may allow you to do more. Maybe the jewelry is simply worth more to you sold. It doesn’t make sense to let thousands of dollars’ worth of value hide in a box on your dresser. Those dollars could be doing a lot more good in, say, your kid’s 529c plan or your retirement fund.

In sum, Cartier jewelry holds its value. If it’s no longer a piece you wear or enjoy, you may want to sell it and use the cash.

FAQs about selling Cartier

Can you sell Cartier?

Yes, you can sell Cartier jewelry — to a jeweler, pawn shop, consignment store, auction house, or to a professional online jewelry buyer. 

Do Cartier watches have resale value?

Yes, like other Cartier jewelry, Cartier watches have a high resale value. Watches Guild reports that many Cartier watches actually increase in value over time. 

More about how to sell watches for the best price.

Can you sell Cartier without paperwork?

Yes, you can sell Cartier without paperwork. While having original Cartier paperwork can authenticate your piece and add to its value, professional jewelry buyers have other ways of determining whether a piece is real. 

Does Cartier buy back their jewelry?

Cartier does not buy back any jewelry, and Cartier does not do trade-ins. In fact, it won’t even take returns if you’ve owned the item for more than 30 days (a small window in case she says ‘no’).

Bottom line: Where is the best place to sell Cartier?

Overall, the best place to sell a used Cartier watch, Cartier LOVE Bracelet, earrings, diamond engagement ring, necklace or other Cartier jewelry is Worthy. Worth is safe, fast and fair.

If your Cartier jewelry doesn’t serve you, then don’t let it take up any more room in your life. Find it a new home and use the income for improving your finances – or, maybe, for buying some new jewelry that’s a great fit for the woman you are today.Have more branded jewelry to sell? Learn about where to get the best prices for a Tiffany engagement ring, Harry Winston diamond, or a David Yurman piece.

Can you sell Cartier?

Yes, you can sell your Cartier jewelry or watch on a wide variety of jewelry and luxury websites, or at a local jeweler, pawnshop or consignment store.

Does Cartier buy back their jewelry?

Cartier does not buy back any jewelry, and Cartier does not do trade-ins.

Is the Cartier resale value high?

According to online consignment site The RealReal, and reported by National Jeweler magazine, Cartier holds the highest resale value of all high-end jewelry brands.

How much can I sell my Cartier watch for?

A few recent Cartier sales from Worthy.com include $2,396 for a Santos, $2,553 for a Tank model and $5,197 for a Dumont.

How much can I sell my Cartier LOVE bracelet for?

According to Rebag, Cartier LOVE bracelets hold 102% of their original value on the resale market, so you may be able to get a good return if you sell your bracelet.

How much can I sell my Cartier ring for?

Cartier rings have been around since the company began. Depending on its age, condition and singularity, your Cartier ring could bring a very decent sum. Recently a round-cut gold ring with numerous small diamonds (about 3.47 carats total) was auctioned for $8,694 at Worthy.com.

Can you sell Cartier without paperwork?

Yes, you can sell Cartier without paperwork. While having original Cartier paperwork can authenticate your piece and add to its value, professional jewelry buyers have other ways of determining whether a piece is real.

Wealthysinglemommy.com founder Emma Johnson is an award-winning business journalist, activist, author and expert. A former Associated Press reporter and MSN Money columnist, Emma has appeared on CNBC, New York Times, Wall Street Journal, NPR, TIME, The Doctors, Elle, O, The Oprah Magazine. Winner of Parents magazine’s “Best of the Web” and a New York Observer “Most Eligible New Yorker," her #1 bestseller, The Kickass Single Mom (Penguin), was a New York Post Must Read. As an expert on divorce and gender, Emma presented at the United Nations Summit for Gender Equality and multiple state legislature hearings. More about Emma's credentials.

2 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *