When should single moms introduce boyfriend to the kids?

I recently heard about a single mom who falls madly and deeply in love with every man she dates, convinced each is her next husband and introduces each guy to her daughter as such. Heartbreak ensues time and again for the kid.

This is an extreme version of what not to do. But the problem doesn’t start at the introduction. The problem is the mom’s expectations of dating.

I’ve said plenty about my stance that you should not hide your dating from your children. Furthermore it is perfectly healthy for your kids to meet someone you’re involved with before you commit for ever and ever — much less hit that supposed magical mark of six months that seems to be the socially acceptable moment that guarantees an emotional safe zone for your offspring to be in the same room with a man for whom you have romantic feelings. It is normal and healthy for you to date. Being ashamed of your sexuality and hiding it from your kids is not healthy.

Related: Which dating sites are best for single moms?

My feelings were confirmed even more a couple months ago when, randomly, on three consecutive Saturdays we welcomed male visitors: one is Steve, a longtime friend who lives in another state and was passing through on work, joining us for breakfast and a tour of the local waterfront. The second is Marc, my single-dad bestie and his young daughter, with whom we spent the day at the beach. The third was a lover, someone I had gone out with, lives far away and made the long trip to see me, and by default, met my kids. He spent a day with me and my kids, who then left for the weekend with their dad.

And guess what? Just as when we hung out with Steve and Marc, my kids were totally cool about hanging out with my lover for an afternoon. They haven’t mentioned him since, and frankly I wonder if they even remember that afternoon.

But they probably would have had I introduced him as my boyfriend.

But I didn’t introduce him as my boyfriend (because he wasn’t), or as their future step-father (uh, not even), or even a friend (because parents use that lie to mask their shame about dating). I didn’t say anything at all, except to introduce everyone by first name, just as with our other guests. I wasn’t sure where that relationship was headed (which, turned out, was down in flames, if you must know), and that was mostly fine with me. Because that is how relationships often go.

And that, I think, is where my dating and parenting divert from the vast majority of people. I very rarely see women spending time with romantic interests for any other reason than to find a husband. And I don’t see much precedent for people in general dating for any other purpose than to hitch up as fulltime mates. Which is fine. But if that is your only goal, then things get confusing as a mom. Because for most people — crazy star-striking-love-at first-sights aside — it takes a long time to know if you want to commit. And when that happens it is very clear, and very different from other types of relationships that may come out of dating.

Here’s an abbreviated list of reasons I date:

Good times. Laughs with a fun, smart guy – why not? I mean, you spend a couple hours at a rom-com and aren’t disappointed that it fails to text the next morning.

Company. Life is lonely. Sometimes I hang out with friends who are annoying because I don’t have anything better to do. Sometimes I go out on dates with men who are annoying because I don’t have anything better to do.

Sex.

Business. Once on OKCupid I was contacted by a gorgeous British plumber who lived in New Jersey at the exact same time I was trying to find a plumber to unclog my toilet.  He thought I was joking when I shared the coincidence. The situation resolved itself before he could come to my rescue (but not without producing plenty of porn-quality fantasies between my ears), but had that worked out it would not have been the first or last professional contact I made through dating.

Friendship. You know Marc I mentioned above? We went on an OKCupid date when we decided to be friends.

In other words, I can find compatibility of all sorts with many different kinds of men. So when something really special comes along, it is easier to discern him from a guy who was valuable for a fun evening or replacing a flush valve. Which brings me to another reason I date:

Looking for love. Duh.

Looking for a husband. Absolutely.

In essence: Dating is life. Parenting is life. Stop making such a big deal out of the former, and the latter becomes far less complicated.

Related posts on single parent dating:

Why single parents should put their kids second when dating

The benefits of dating single dads

Why single moms should disclose their income in online dating

Tips for dating a single mom (12 things NOT to say)

Dating coach: “Single moms are hot on the successful-men market”

Single moms discuss dating, sex and kids

My single mom friend Morghan and I discussed this topic in detail, inspired because we both had a bad reaction to a recent Huffington Post article discouraging single parents from rushing into introducing a potential mate to the kids. She is a fellow single mom to two preschoolers, and a divorce lawyer and mediator.

Last night we IM'd about the article and when to introduce a boyfriend to the kids:

Me: So what was the one thing about that HuffPo article that really ticked you off?

Morghan: It bothered me that somehow mom isn’t allowed to have a sexual side because that might make her teenage kid uncomfortable. Like parents should hide the fact that they are full people, and that kids should be sheltered from that part of their lives. Which renders their personal lives as unseemly.

Me: I totally agree. It shames the whole idea of a parent as a sexual, dating person. Puts a negative spin on it for all parties, including – especially — the kids.

Morghan: We aren't afraid to give our kids Xbox360 and blast-your-head-off war games, but they’re not allowed to see mom date.

Me: Ha! Excellent point.

Related: Podcast episode answers the question:

Should I tell my ex I have a boyfriend?


Morghan: I'm not saying every Tom, Dick and Harry need to have dinner at the house, but seems like the kids may be better adjusted in the long run if they aren't kept in the dark.

Dating is a normal part of life — including for single moms

Me: Of course we are all concerned about hurting our kids. But I agree that that making dating a normal part of life — not some colossal deal just because our kids meet someone we're involved with — lessens the blow if and when those relationships should end.

Morghan: Well put.

Me: But what do we say to the status quo which says, “It’s normal for you to have several relationships after your divorce, and it hurts so much for the parent when those ends. It's not fair to subject your kids to that same pain”?

If and when the relationship ends …

Morghan: To them I’d say: Kids need to see how we recover from the blow of relationships ending. Why isn't that healthy? I tend to wonder if the people screaming the loudest about this aren’t shifting fire from their own overly bitter divorce that most like served to hurt their children more than some light dating ever could.

W_Banner_Blog_WealthySingleMommy_0816_02_Turquoise

Me: We won't throw stones at those miserable assholes. But to your point – I think there is huge value in teaching our kids that life is about loving, then loosing, then picking ourselves up and forgiving and learning to love and trust again.

Morghan: I don't think it serves them well to shield them from that.

Me: I mean, love always ends. Always. Divorce, breakups, death, or love just dies in a regular, old unhappy marriage. Plus, by embracing dating — it embraces the fact that half of people have been divorcing for 40 YEARS! OUR CHILDREN WILL DIVORCE! They will have multiple long-term relationships! THAT IS LIFE TODAY!

Morghan: Call me a romantic but I still believe in marriage and love. Divorce is not akin to death and taxes. But I guess that is where we part ways.

Me: I’m also incredibly romantic. I totally believe in marriage and love. I also believe that we have no choice but to accept that they both end. They just do. That is why we're having this convo :)

Morghan: And honestly, I hope my children learn from my mistakes and don't have to suffer through a divorce. But they will most definitely suffer through break-ups, heart breaks and failure.

Me: There is another side of this. I’ll share a personal story. I was involved with this guy Larry for a year, and he definitely knew the kids and saw them regularly. But it was also clear that there were limits to how much he was willing to be involved. And one day the kids and I were in Brooklyn for some family event, and Helena asks where we are, and I tell her, and she says, “Larry lives in Brooklyn! Can we go to his house?!” They had never been to his house. And it was like a stab to the gut – it was clear that I was participating in a big party that they were not invited to.

Single mom with a lover on the side

Morghan: To a certain extent, isn't some of that party just for you?

Me: Well, yes. That was the extent of that particular relationship. But that is not how I want to raise my kids. Or the relationship I want with them – I don’t want that distance that having two separate lives creates.

Morghan: I think it is hard to just set a marker for everyone because every relationship is different.

Me: Of course.

Morghan: But I don't think that means we should be hiding anything. Plus, the fact that our kids are so young makes it easier. They seem so accepting of things.

Me: I totally agree (both our kids are almost 3 and 5). But what about people who say, “Determine the time to introduce depending on how your kid will react”? I say – fuck that. We are the parents and we decide. If we feel our partners should be part of the family in some way, that is what goes. We don’t cower to a kid’s tantrum!

Morghan: Yes, agreed. And as a parent you have to address however your kid reacts – because that is your job as a parent to help them work through it, not avoid it.

On one board, a mom pointed out that her ex's girlfriend broke up with him after meeting the kids (at the six month mark) and that was even harder because the kids felt guilty.

Me: That is too bad. It’s the parent's job to make sure they understand that it is NOT their fault (again, it's not all about the kids!) and here is how we face that adversity.

A lesson in adversity

Morghan: Agreed. I said this earlier: I’d rather know that I taught them to face adversity than to just be in constant search for happiness. Happiness changes. How you face the difficulties of life is a skill that is being ignored because it doesn't make kids happy.

Me: I more or less agree, but those things go hand-in-hand. You have to be strong to get through all the lousy stuff that happens in life and believe that happiness exists on the other side.

Morghan: I think happiness is within – not out there.

Me: OK, Yoda.

Morghan: I was being serious.

Me: On one board I heard a mom say something like, “If I want to actually build a relationship, I need to spend time with a man, and that means that he has to come and hang out at my house. We can't build something by seeing each other once every two weeks because we have kids.” It often comes down to schedules and practicality. Which is life.

Morghan: Exactly.

Me: This was super-stupid in the article: However, remember that you have children now so it isn't quite the same as it was before. Children often become embarrassed and confused when seeing their parents act like adolescents.

Single moms are told to be ashamed of their sexualities

Morghan: That totally pissed me off. Like we shouldn't let our kids see us experience life. Whomever wrote that needs a bitch slap.

Me: Or get laid!

Morghan: Maybe that is why this experience of dating now is so much like middle school. That is how middle schoolers react – “Oh, don't let anyone know so and so is growing arm hair!”

Me: HAHAH!

Morghan: Parents falter, and kids need to see it.

Me: So true.

Morghan: So maybe if we’re open about our relationships our kids will have an easier time in middle school. LOL

Me: LOL. Also, it's about owning this as normal adult human behavior: People need companionship, and it is hard to find good mates, and we get our hearts broken and act foolish, but also find great love that can bleed into the rest of the family.

Morghan: Yes, I definitely agree. Great love that should bleed into the family. I say, there is no limit on how many people can or should love my kids.

Me: I so agree! Another thought:

Why are we so opposed to our kids becoming attached, and that person leaving? For example, Helena's BFF at school Eleanor is moving in the summer. Hopefully we’ll stay in touch, but let's get real- that likely won't happen, even though I'm very fond of her mom who is my friend.

That doesn't mean we hang out with them any less, or discourage the girls’ closeness. Truly caring for someone is a precious thing, and should not be avoided just because it might hurt one day.

Morghan: Right, people lose people and it fucking hurts. But it happens.

Me: Shit happens, kids!

Morghan: And we have to model for our kids to learn how to cope.

Me: Yes, coping. But I also think a lot about how I want my kids to see me in loving relationships with other people – men, friends, etc.

Morghan: Right.

Me: Growing up, my mom dated a bunch at various times, and I loved that. But she never had any serious relationships, and that was way worse — I didn't have ANY model for relationships, good or bad. I saw that she never got over her divorce and saw that as a huge fail.

Morghan: Ouch.

Single moms can teach their kids healthy dating attitudes

Me: I want my kids to see resilience, and to me resilience means loving again. Not just coping with loss. Which brings us again back to the when.

Morghan: Kids do have to be in the mix to see if the relationship is going to work. In my case, I thought I didn’t want anything serious, and so I brought my kids around my new boyfriend as a deterrent – and then watched in awe as this guy threw himself into the mix with them. Then I realized that was something worth exploring.

Me: You tried to sabotage the relationship with your kids, but they just sweetened the deal.

Morghan. Exactly! But I really don’t see why bringing a potential mate around the kids is shameful.

Me: Word to your mother! Or, Word to you, mother!

Morghan: LOL

Me: LOL. One thing that I feel strongly about is people who (and this is you, sorry) say, “Oh we'll just tell the kids we're friends hanging out.” Kids know everything.

Morghan: They do – but I have a hard time finding where to draw the line between what is age appropriate information.

Don't lie to the kids — they understand everything anyway

Me: I think the general rule should be THEY ALL UNDERSTAND EVEYTHHING . Lucas was tiny — not even 2 — and we were reading the Dinosaurs Divorce book and he pointed out that, “Mommy kisses Larry.” It wasn't like we were making out in front of the kids! Just a hello peck. And even though he was 1, Lucas understood there was something different there.

Morghan: Right – so at what point are we to give them the tools to articulate dating?

Me: It depends on the kid, of course, but the same rules apply no matter what — we do what we think is right, address their concerns, keep things real.

Morghan: So my story ends with my “friend” playing with Ozzie at the dining table, while my ex has come over and is packing lunches. I’m furiously blow-drying my hair to get ready for work.

Me: That's a good story!

Morghan: Then it hit me: I'm in the Twilight Zone. I don't think most people experience that.

Me: And you also got sex and a homemade breakfast in the Twilight Zone, correct? Not to mention unpaid childcare. I think I just had an orgasm typing that.

 

Related:

I was pleased but also a little surprise by all the positive response bestowed upon my recent post, My boyfriend slept over for the first time and hilarity (and normalcy) ensued.

Clearly there is a whole lot of sentiment out there that you are a filthy whore if you are a mom and you seek out romantic companionship. Ty commented:

As a single mom, it is a social stigma for me to date. Many feel that my life as a woman should have stopped when I had children. Someone even suggested that it’s okay for men to move on but I should solely dedicate my life to my children. 

That makes me want to bust out my nunchucks and beat the crap out of society. But you are safe here, and I’m here to tell you: Date! It’s normal — healthy!  There will likely be heartbreak and missteps. You are human. But do not feel ashamed of your emotional, social or sexual needs. Embrace your womanhood in all its splendor. This is what a good mom does.

And when you are ready, bring around your family. Yes, consider how you do this. Respect your kids’ reactions. Talk about it with them. But do not feel guilty. Let go of any shame. You are normal and this is healthy.

That said, there are plenty of good reasons to take your time introducing your kids to your new amore. Maybe you don’t ever introduce him at all.

Here are some good reasons you may want to delay or forego integrating your new guy into your family:

1. You recently broke up with someone else.

Even though you may be ready to move on, you’re not sure your kids are.

2. You’re afraid your new guy will be really awesome with the kids.

Which will make you totally love him even way, way more. Maybe you’re not ready for that kind of emotional intensity. It scares you. That’s cool. Take it slow.

3. You’re afraid he might not be so great with your kids.

That doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t date him — it means that he might not be part of your family life. Sometimes you just need a lover or someone to take you out to dinner now and again. Not all relationships are the giant, Brady Bunch, 24/7 kind. Maybe you’ll want that sort of partnership in another phase of your journey.

4. You want to prolong the courtship.

Face it: if he’s spending every Wednesday enjoying meatloaf and mashed potatoes with you and the kids,  he’s not taking you out of wild-boar-and-crimini-mushroom meatloaf and truffle-laced heirloom purple potato mash at that cute place downtown on Wednesdays. Family life is wonderful. But that shit’s not glamorous.

5. You’re afraid your family life will make him run.

Truth? It might. Especially if he doesn’t love you (yet). It’s  hard to imagine that a man who did not sire your kids might actually like them and also want to fuck you. But it happens all the time. Maybe you want feel more secure in the relationship before you bring him home to the circus that is your life. Take your time!

6.  You don’t want to signal to him it’s serious (yet). 

You may accept that introducing a guy to your kids does not indicate that he’s your forever boo. But he may not see it that way — which is understandable because most people in our culture wouldn’t, either. If you’re playing it cool and not ready to jump in with your heart and soul, but worry he will think you’re eager and commitment-ready if you invite him to join your clan for Disney on Ice, wait.

7. You want him all to yourself.

This is not selfish. See #3. Not every relationship is meant for marriage or family. Having a lover that is separate from your daily life can be a fabulous arrangement. If that suits you, embrace it.

 

About Emma Johnson

Emma Johnson is a veteran money journalist, noted blogger, bestselling author and an host of the award-winning podcast, Like a Mother with Emma Johnson. A former Associated Press Financial Wire reporter and MSN Money columnist, Emma has written for the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Forbes, Glamour, Oprah.com, U.S. News, Parenting, USA Today and others. Her #1 bestseller, The Kickass Single Mom (Penguin), was named to the New York Post's ‘Must Read” list.Emma regularly comments on issues of modern families, gender equality, divorce, sex and motherhood for outlets like CNN, Headline News, New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Fox & Friends, CNBC, NPR, TIME, MONEY, O, The Oprah Magazine and The Doctors. She was named Parents magazine’s “Best of the Web,” “Top 15 Personal Finance Podcasts” by U.S. News, and a “Most Eligible New Yorker” by New York Observer.A popular speaker, Emma presented at the United Nations Summit for Gender Equality. Read more about Emma here.

53 Comments

  1. Carrie on August 31, 2016 at 10:01 am

    I had a horrible ordeal where I had to leave my child’s father due to drug issues, I have sole custody and am back on my feet. By some amazing turn of events I have met someone I connect on every level with. We have only been together two months, my child is under two and I would like us to spend more time together, I question sleepovers only because there are a few people in my life chastising me for even giving it a thought. I am now starting to feel selfish for wanting these things and encouraging progression to the next level of this relationship.

  2. Former single mother (the five year wait was WORTH IT) on January 30, 2017 at 8:45 am

    What a grievous shame it is that you would feel more strongly about your own selfish desire, and the need of children to feel secure at home. That actually includes the way you approach your sex life. (home, as I referred it here, is a well packed word that encompasses a LOT more than mere place… it’s everything)

    As a grown child of a single mother, sex addict, actually, with an endless supply of eager men who by my mother’s example, felt NO need to protect us from anything (because it was HER life and we were just a part of it) we learned to distrust. Everyone. Everything. My brother’s grew up wondering if the girls they liked were really just playing with their hearts, all the while well into adulthood I cringe at movies depicting the mom’s sleepover helping himself to orange juice in the morning. Orange juice provided by the single mother. Orange juice that was meant for the children. But the orange juice is just the surface, subtle but tangible standin for what those men, and the children’s mother are actually giving away- robbing from their children, from YOU!

    If you want to go out and “enjoy your sex life” reclaim YOUR sexuality, whatever, keep in mind that that’s how some of us ended up with half siblings and our mother’s increasing resentment of the little people she created holding her back from what SHE wants.

    Don’t bring your dude around until you know the man (and you’re fooling yourself if you actually think that sex helps you know a person… it does… in a very intimate soul bonding sort of way that can only authentically be expressed in marriage -otherwise, it’s a premature bonding agent that KEEPS you from seeing a person, but damages you, and your children), know his friends, know his family. He should know you have kids, and if he’s a man worth taking home to meet them, he’ll see your nonchalance about your children’s well being (and safety) as a red flag.

    Hell, if you feel that selfishly for your human sex toys, you’re frankly not ready to date. You’re probably not suitable to be trusted with the fragile vulnerabilities your children carry with them; take a deep look at what you’re teaching them about their own self worth, their own sexuality, love… life, It’s NOT about you anymore. Grow up!

    • Former single mother (the five year wait was WORTH IT) on January 30, 2017 at 9:02 am

      That “and” in the first line should have read, “than”.

  3. Luis on June 30, 2017 at 11:57 am

    No kid wants to jump in the bed with a strange man when their scared in the middle of the night. Just saying.

  4. Executioner on July 10, 2017 at 3:13 pm

    You go girl!!!
    Why don’t you have sex with a new stranger every week? But don’t forget to make your kids know they can’t rely on you whenever you are “spending time with him” aka getting fucked, give them a shitty example of how healthy relationships should work and off course that they deserve to be exposed to adult themes at an early age because you obviously can’t help it.

    And if your aren’t tired of being a disastrous single mother (not that you don’t deserve to be one)
    you may as well want to take the risk of them getting mistreated or even molested by “mommy’s special friend”. your house your rules :)

    And why would children need wholesome parental figures anyways? it’s never you fault :(
    You have been negligent enough to bring them this world,even though you’re aware you can’t even take care of your own life.

    You are selfish and probably mentally ill.

  5. Single_Mom on November 1, 2017 at 5:40 am

    Hi. I find your article very interesting. I disagree with a lot of the other comments. My kid’s father died when she was 3. She’s 8 now. On my 33rd birthday I saw myself getting old and dying alone so I started dating again. My instincts have never failed me. I am not a selfish parent and I know the little person I brought into this world. I think that should be every parent’s barometer–your own kid. You raised that child, you know him/her better than anyone. After reading your article and the many of the vitriolic comments, I refuse to judge. I do not know your children or their children, but I do know I have a right to be happy. I have a responsibility to this little kid I brought to the world. And that I have to be fair to the other person I am bringing into my life, and my child’s. I want to thank you because your article help put things into perspective, and that is to trust my judgement. I thank you for this.

  6. Francheska on June 26, 2018 at 6:07 pm

    I am currently dating someone I really like and came across this article for advise. I am in my early 40’s, my children are now either grown or in high school. My ex and I had a horrible, horrible breakup which for a while left me emotionally detached, untrusting of men but also with the impression that all men will eventually cheat on you. Nine years later my ex has since remarried(4 years now) while I had the liberty of spending the first five years of our breakup rebuilding my faith and trust in men, helping my daughters through the struggles they faced due to the breakup, adjusting my kids to a new life, being strong for them and hiding any struggles we may have been going through financially due to the results of that disfunctional relationship. Through all this I never gave up on love and at that time dated ( 5 guys) but my girls only were introduced to those that I formed a relationship with ( 1). As I felt no need to introduce them to someone I was not sure about. Fast forward as I say nine years later the past 4 years have been hell on my dating life. My daughters are now old enough to date themselves or are asking questions. I have opted to now be more transparent about my dating life for a couple of reasons. 1. For my safety, I provide a picture, location and my dates contact information to my children before going on any date with any man. ( before this was provided to my sisters). 2. They are dating now and are looking at me and the way that I handle my relationships and dating techniques also because I could no longer hide it from them. ( kids are smarter than you think) However, I find that now that the cat is out the bag dating is much harder for me now. When I hit 40 I went through the 40 year old midlife crisis of why haven’t I found the right guy, serial dating, etc…it’s like I got worse. I don’t know if it’s because I know my kids will all soon be grown and I don’t want to be alone or WHAT!! But it has changed. However even through all that I never introduced them to anyone. Although they know of them they have never met any of them however I think I may have a winner and would love to introduce my girls to him eventually if things work out. I tell my story because I felt it was important for other single people to know that dating is hard and no matter how you present it to your kids , now or later kids will form an opinion regardless. I sometimes have my girls compare Dads relationship to me dating as if they feel sorry because I haven’t found anyone. But I had to explain to them that ” Mommy found SOMEONE quite a few time, I’m just waiting on the right one”. Dating with children doesn’t have to be complicated for our children or us if we don’t want it to be.

Leave a Comment