scroll top

Walmart vs. Aldi vs. Target: Which Thanksgiving dinner deal makes sense for your table?

We earn commissions for transactions made through links in this post. Here's more on how we make money.

Thanksgiving dinner for ten for about $35? Walmart is offering just that this year, with turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, three casseroles, rolls, and the ingredients for pumpkin pie. Aldi has a meal for ten for under $39, including a bigger 16-pound turkey. And Target is putting together a $30 Thanksgiving spread for six.

They’re all appealing deals, but the menus are quite different. Walmart gives you more sides, Aldi puts a generous bird and the classics on the table, and Target makes Thanksgiving for a smaller group wonderfully straightforward. All three are grocery offers that you cook at home, with final totals depending on your store and the weight of your turkey.

What each Thanksgiving deal buys you

Roasted turkey and Thanksgiving sides on a long table
Image Credit: Walmart

Walmart: about $3.50 per person for a dinner serving ten. There’s a Butterball turkey, mashed and sweet potatoes, stuffing, green bean and corn casseroles, cranberry sauce, rolls, and ingredients for pumpkin pie with whipped topping. It’s the most generous selection of sides in this comparison.

Aldi: under $3.90 per person for ten, with a 16-pound turkey, stuffing, sweet potatoes, peas, fresh cranberries, rolls, vegetables, and pumpkin pie ingredients. It’s a traditional, uncomplicated menu with a particularly good-sized centerpiece.

Target: $5 per person for six. The meal includes a Butterball turkey weighing up to ten pounds, potatoes, stuffing, green bean casserole ingredients, rolls, jarred gravy, and canned cranberry sauce. Those two ready-made extras save a little work, although dessert isn’t included.

Walmart gives a table of ten the most sides

Groceries included in Walmart’s Holiday Meal Basket
Image Credit: Walmart

For a big Thanksgiving table, Walmart’s about $35 for 10, or $3.50 a person, is a strong offer. Along with the Butterball turkey, the basket includes the makings of mashed potatoes and gravy, stuffing, cranberry sauce, green bean casserole, sweet potato casserole, and corn casserole. You also get rolls and pumpkin pie ingredients with whipped topping. There’s enough variety here for guests who like to try a little of everything.

Walmart’s $35 estimate is based on a 13.5-pound turkey and about 3.2 pounds of sweet potatoes, so the weight of the produce and poultry can change your checkout total. You’ll also want to see whether you have basics such as eggs and butter for the recipes. The offer runs from October 28 through December 24, except in Alaska, Hawaii, Oklahoma, Puerto Rico, and Wisconsin; pickup or delivery charges may apply.





The turkey price is worth a closer look when comparing Walmart with Aldi. Walmart advertises Butterball turkey at 97 cents per pound. A 16-pound bird would cost $15.52, which is about $2.43 more than the 13.5-pound bird used in Walmart’s $35 estimate. With everything else unchanged, that brings the basket to roughly $37.43. It still looks like a very competitive dinner, even with a turkey closer to Aldi’s size.

The shoppable list is useful because you can add the whole basket to your cart, then take out what you already own. Maybe you have plenty of stuffing mix, or nobody wants corn casserole. If your Thanksgiving tradition calls for mashed potatoes, gravy, green beans, and a homemade pie, Walmart makes it easy to get most of those ingredients in one go.

Aldi gives you a bigger turkey and a simpler menu

Aldi Thanksgiving meal promotion for ten
Image Credit: Aldi

Aldi’s under $39 for 10 meal includes a 16-pound turkey, making it especially attractive if your family enjoys generous portions and leftover turkey sandwiches. You also get stuffing, Hawaiian sweet rolls, sweet potatoes, peas, fresh cranberries, carrots, celery, and the ingredients for pumpkin pie. At under $3.90 per person, it’s a lovely holiday spread for the money.

The Aldi menu is slightly simpler than Walmart’s. It doesn’t include mashed white potatoes or gravy, so add those if they’re Thanksgiving essentials at your house. The cranberries are fresh, which is great for homemade sauce, although you’ll need sugar from the pantry. Aldi’s advertised prices run through Nov. 25, with no coupon, membership, or loyalty card required; the total varies by store and what’s available.

Aldi includes three boxes of stuffing and two bags of frozen peas, so you’re not short of those sides for a table of ten. You can make the cranberry sauce ahead of time and leave it in the fridge until dinner. The peas take only a few minutes to heat, and the carrots and celery make an easy vegetable platter while the turkey roasts.

That 16-pound turkey is the main attraction here. It gives you a good chance of having leftovers for sandwiches, soup, or a pot pie, provided the bird is the right size for your guests. Make sure your roasting pan is big enough and your fridge has room for safe thawing. For a family that likes a classic turkey dinner without half a dozen casseroles, Aldi is especially tempting.

Target keeps the bill lowest for six

Russet potatoes sold by Target
Image Credit: Target

Target’s $30 for six Thanksgiving meal is the lowest total bill of the three advertised offers, at $5 per person. The menu includes a Butterball turkey up to ten pounds, a three-pound bag of russet potatoes, stuffing mix, and everything for green bean casserole. Two take-and-bake baguettes stand in for dinner rolls, while the gravy and cranberry sauce are already prepared.





Dessert isn’t part of Target’s basket, but its seasonal selection includes $5 pies. Add one, if it’s stocked at your store, and the Thanksgiving bill rises to around $35 before tax. If your guests are bringing dessert, the $30 meal already covers the savory essentials. The offer is valid through Nov. 29, excluding Alaska and Hawaii.

Target has another useful option if you prefer to build your own menu: its Good & Gather frozen turkey is advertised separately at 79 cents per pound, where available. That’s not the Butterball turkey in the meal offer. At that rate, a ten-pound bird would be $7.90, leaving $22.10 before you’ve reached the price of the full six-person basket. It’s worth considering when you’ve already got stuffing, gravy, and vegetables in the pantry.

How the math changes with your guest count

A person carving a roasted turkey at the table
Image Credit: Walmart

Two to four people. Target’s $30 basket comes to $7.50 each when four people share the cost, or $15 each for two, before you count any leftovers. You can still enjoy the meal over several days, especially if you’ve got room to freeze cooked turkey. For a quieter Thanksgiving, a smaller turkey breast and just a couple of favorite sides might suit the table even better.

Six people. Target’s meal fits this guest count neatly, with a starting price about $5 below Walmart’s basket. But Walmart includes pie ingredients and more sides, while Target offers ready-made gravy and cranberry sauce. Add a $5 pie to Target’s cart and the advertised starting totals are roughly level. Decide whether you’d rather have the extra dishes or the simpler cooking job.

Eight people. Walmart’s basket works out to about $4.38 per guest at the advertised total, and its assortment of sides should be welcome around a larger table. Target’s basket is designed for six, so you’d have only about $5 to add food before matching Walmart’s starting price. The size of the turkey is especially important once you’re feeding two extra people.

Ten people. Walmart and Aldi are both built around this many guests. Walmart has the fuller menu, including mashed potatoes, gravy, and several casseroles; Aldi’s draw is the 16-pound turkey and a simpler collection of sides. Two Target baskets would come to $60 before dessert, making the ten-person offers much more appealing for a larger gathering.

What to check before you buy

A garnished roasted turkey on a serving platter
Image Credit: Walmart

Before choosing, look at the actual items available at your nearest store, especially the turkey sizes. Both Walmart’s and Aldi’s advertised totals depend on the weight of the bird. If you’re ordering for pickup or delivery, check for fees and substitutions too. There’s no sense losing a $4 or $5 price advantage because the checkout total changed at the last minute.





Have a quick look through the recipes for the dishes you’re planning. The baskets provide many of the main ingredients, but you may still need eggs for pumpkin pie, butter for stuffing, or milk for mashed potatoes. It’s useful to see how many recipes can share the same ingredients, rather than buying a separate carton or package for each dish.

Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, Nov. 26, so turkey thawing needs a place in the plan. Allow roughly one day in the refrigerator for every four to five pounds of frozen turkey. That means about two to three days for a ten-pound bird and around four days for a 16-pound one. Once thawed, a turkey can stay refrigerated for another one to two days before cooking. A frozen 16-pound bird bought on Aldi’s Nov. 25 final offer day won’t have time to thaw safely in the fridge by Thanksgiving.

Oven space is the other thing worth planning. Bake a pie the day before if you’re making one, and use the stovetop for peas or gravy while the turkey roasts. Have shallow containers ready for the extra food, particularly if you’re buying a larger bird for leftovers. Refrigerate leftovers within two hours, then eat them within three to four days or freeze them for later.

For six guests, Target’s $30 meal is a convenient choice, particularly if you like the ready-made gravy and cranberry sauce. For ten, Walmart offers the fullest spread at about $35, while Aldi’s under-$39 basket is especially attractive for the larger turkey. Any of the three can put an enjoyable Thanksgiving dinner on the table without a huge grocery bill.